This is issue of (obsolete) Windows Game Controllers.

Because you have changed some parameters in the device (Arduino) in another computer, e.g. number of axes and or buttons, VIP/PID and or device name.

In Windows Register remains the old reference, then the error in Game Controllers > Properties. So delete in Windows Register for old controller name references, can search by name or VID/PID before plug.

But for VKB Button Tester (included in MMJoy1 package) or games controls, the controller is fully operational.